Hawaiʻi Healthcare Task Force

Hawaiʻi's Physician Growth Is Bypassing Independent Practice: Hawaiʻi Healthcare Task Force

Since 2017 the number of physicians in Hawaiʻi's large groups has grown 67%. The number in small practice has slipped.

Evidence brief. Analysis by David Isei, MPH, MAOL, PMP, Executive Director, Hawaiʻi Healthcare Task Force.

Intro: Since 2017 the number of physicians in Hawaiʻi's large groups has grown 67%. The number in small practice has slipped. No state agency records when a practice closes, sells or changes owners. This brief counts what public federal files allow, and names what only the state can supply.

Headline cards

- Large groups +67%: Physicians in groups of ten or more: 1,641 in October 2017, 2,742 in September 2026.

- Small practice −6%: Physicians alone or in groups of five or fewer: 1,099 to 1,033. Best stated as a fall of 6 to 10%.

- Small-practice share 26.3%: Down from 37.8% of physicians with a Hawaiʻi practice address.

- New arrivals 77%: Of 2,241 physicians new to the Hawaiʻi list since 2017, the share now in groups of ten or more.

Section 1. The count: Large groups took almost all of the growth

The Task Force read thirteen CMS physician listings from 2016 to 2026 and counted every physician with a Hawaiʻi practice address by the size of the group they practice in. Physicians on the list rose from 2,909 to 3,925. Small practice held nearly level in number and lost ground in share.

SnapshotTotalSmallMidLargeSmall-practice share
Oct 201729091099169164137.8%
Apr 201827461039190151737.8%
Oct 201931031075116191234.6%
Dec 20203126983172197131.4%
Dec 20213248980169209930.2%
Dec 20223420978167227528.6%
Jul 20233442993157229228.8%
Jan 20243550948141246126.7%
Jan 20253611927175250925.7%
Dec 20253749994168258726.5%
Jun 202640431013173285725.1%
Sep 202639251033150274226.3%
July 2016 (older listing rules, not used in the count)30861301147163842.2%

The rise in the first half of 2026 is national: the whole CMS file grew 9% in those six months. Ending at December 2025, before that rise, gives 994 small-practice physicians and a fall of 10% from 2017, so the fall is best stated as 6 to 10%.

Source: Task Force analysis of thirteen CMS Physician Compare and Doctors and Clinicians files, July 2016 to September 2026 (2016 to 2019 from openICPSR project 149961). July 2016 is shown but not used: it has 202 more small-practice physicians than October 2017, a step the billing files for the same months do not show, so it most likely follows older listing rules. Group size counts only physicians with a Hawaiʻi address. The list grew by a third while the University of Hawaiʻi's count of practicing physicians stayed flat, so part of the falling share is the list.

A second federal file points the same way

In the wider Medicare billing file, which includes physicians who serve Hawaiʻi from elsewhere, small-practice physicians fell from 1,223 in August 2016 to 1,040 in September 2026, down 15%. In September 2026, 3,894 of that file's 5,838 physicians were listed with a Hawaiʻi practice address. The neighbor islands lost the largest share.

Honolulu; 826; 687; -17%; 259 (31%); 288

Hawaiʻi; 142; 110; -23%; 55 (39%); 51

Maui; 89; 64; -28%; 56 (63%); 36

Kauaʻi; 33; 21; -36%; 16 (48%); 7

Not placed; 133; 158; +19%; 99 (74%); 101

Source: Task Force analysis of CMS Medicare Fee-For-Service Public Provider Enrollment files, with 2016 to 2019 snapshots from the NBER archive. County is taken from the practice location of the billing group, and neighbor-island counts are small. "Not placed" is physicians whose billing group lists no Hawaiʻi practice location. Billing group is a stand-in for ownership, not a record of it. These numbers are not interchangeable with the Hawaiʻi-address count above.

Section 2. Who left, who arrived: Small practice is lost to departure more than to employment

Following the same physicians from file to file shows where they went. Few small-practice physicians moved into a large group. Far more left the Hawaiʻi list, and most of those finished medical school in 1986 or earlier.

Flow A, the 1,099 small-practice physicians of October 2017, as of September 2026: 516 still in small practice; 457 no longer listed in Hawaiʻi; 96 moved to a group of ten or more; 30 moved to a group of six to nine.

Flow B, the 2,241 physicians new to the Hawaiʻi list since 2017: 1,723 joined a group of ten or more; 423 small practice; 95 group of six to nine.

287 of 456. Of those no longer listed with a graduation year on file, the number who finished medical school in 1986 or earlier.

517 in, 583 out. Physicians who came into small practice and physicians who left it. About nine arrivals for every ten departures.

42% and 42%. Share of 2017 large-group and small-practice physicians no longer listed. The rates match. Large groups gained far more physicians than they lost.

Note: Leaving the list is not proof of a closure. It covers retirement, relocation, death and dropping Medicare. The count cannot tell an owner from an employee.

Section 3. The wider record: The nation is further down the same road

- Hawaiʻi physicians who are employed: from 56% in 2016 to 69% in 2025. The University did not publish the share for 2021 to 2023. Source: University of Hawaiʻi Physician Workforce Assessment.

YearEmployed share
201656
201854.5
202058
202469
202569

- U.S. physicians in private practice: from 60.1% in 2012 to 42.2% in 2024. Source: AMA Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, 2024.

YearPrivate practiceOwnership
201260.153.2
201456.850.8
201655.847.1
20185445.9
202049.144
202246.744
202442.235.4

- −43%: Independent physicians in the rural United States, from 21,956 in 2019 to 12,467 in 2024.

- −42%: Independent practices in the rural United States over the same years.

- 23%: Hawaiʻi's statewide physician shortage. Hawaiʻi County 43%, Maui 41%, Kauaʻi 28%, Honolulu 15% (University of Hawaiʻi).

Note: Rural figures: PAI-Avalere, Rural Physician Employment and Acquisition Trends, 2019 to 2024. PAI advocates for physician practices. Its analysis is not peer-reviewed.

The Hawaiʻi record, without names:

- The physicians and staff of an independent Hilo primary care practice became part of a mainland-based medical group on 1 February 2026.

- A commercial insurer and a hospital system filed with the U.S. Department of Justice for clearance to combine under a new parent organization, as reported on 9 April 2026. State agencies are reviewing it as well.

Sources: the acquiring group's announcement of 2 February 2026 and Hawaiʻi Public Radio, 9 April 2026. No terms of either transaction are described here. Neither event is evidence of harm by itself. The first appears in no state record, and the second is under review only because of its size.

Section 4. The squeeze: Why a small practice is getting harder to keep open

A practice closes or sells when what comes in stops covering what it takes to stay open. A large organization spreads fixed costs across hundreds of physicians. A practice of three cannot.

- −33%: Medicare physician payment after practice-cost inflation, 2001 to 2026. Practice costs rose 59% (AMA).

- 40 a week: Prior authorization requests per physician, taking 13 hours. 95% of physicians say it delays care and 26% report a serious adverse event (AMA 2025 survey of 1,000 physicians).

- 61.8%: Hawaiʻi Medicare beneficiaries in Medicare Advantage plans in 2024, against 54.8% nationally (CMS).

National | Payment against costs | Medicare physician payment fell 33% after practice-cost inflation from 2001 to 2026. Practice costs rose 59% from 2001 to 2025. | American Medical Association

National | Prior authorization | 40 requests per physician every week, taking 13 hours of physician and staff time. 95% of physicians say it delays care and 26% report a serious adverse event for a patient. | AMA 2025 prior authorization survey of 1,000 physicians

Hawaiʻi | Prior authorization in Hawaiʻi | Payers must report prior authorization data to the state each year under Act 151 of 2025, and a preliminary first report is out. No one has measured the time Hawaiʻi practices spend on it. | Act 151 of 2025; State Health Planning and Development Agency

National | Regulatory load | 95% of practices say the burden grew over three years. 40% keep three or more full-time administrative staff per physician. | MGMA 2026 Regulatory Burden Report of more than 230 practices

National | Desk work and coding | Nearly 2 hours of record-keeping and desk work for every hour with patients, plus 1 to 2 hours at night. | Sinsky and colleagues, Annals of Internal Medicine, 2016

National | Thin reserves | After the 2024 claims-system outage, 55% of responding practices used personal funds and 31% could not make payroll. | AMA informal survey of 1,400 respondents

National | Site of service | Medicare pays a hospital outpatient department more than a physician office for the same service. That gives hospitals a reason to buy practices. | MedPAC and KFF

Hawaiʻi | Cost of living | Prices are 10% above the national average, second highest of any state. Rents are 25% above. | U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis, 2024

Hawaiʻi | Pay against cost of living | The University cites low physician payment compared with the cost of living as a cause of the shortage. Federal wage data for May 2025 put the mean pay of employed Hawaiʻi family physicians 13% below the national mean. | University of Hawaiʻi Physician Workforce Assessment; U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2025

Hawaiʻi | Tax on medical services | Hawaiʻi taxed the gross receipts of medical practices. An exemption for Medicare, Medicaid and TRICARE payments took effect on 1 January 2026. The Department of Taxation estimated it at $74.1 million for fiscal 2026. | Act 47 of 2024; Department of Taxation estimate as cited by the University of Hawaiʻi Rural Health Research and Policy Center

Hawaiʻi | Few insurers | Hawaiʻi is the third least competitive commercial insurance market in the country. The largest insurer holds 66% and the top two hold 88%. | AMA, Competition in Health Insurance, 2026 update

Hawaiʻi | Medicare Advantage | 61.8% of Hawaiʻi Medicare beneficiaries were in Medicare Advantage plans in 2024, and it has been a majority since at least 2014. Three of the top five burdens practices name are tied to those plans. | CMS Geographic Variation 2024 and MGMA 2026

Hawaiʻi | Departures | In 2025 at least 81 physicians retired, 14 died and more than 88 moved away. | University of Hawaiʻi Physician Workforce Assessment

Hawaiʻi | An aging workforce | Hawaiʻi physicians average 55.4 years old against 54.4 nationally. 804 of them, about one in four, are 65 or older. | University of Hawaiʻi Physician Workforce Assessment report to the 2026 Legislature

National | No successors | 68% of final-year residents rank hospital employment in their top two choices. 6% rank solo practice. 61% had no training in the business of medicine. | AMN Healthcare 2023 survey of 241 residents

Hawaiʻi | What cuts the other way | Medicare's practice-expense index for Hawaiʻi is 1.137, which is above the state's price level of 110. Its physician-work index is held at the national 1.000, so the gap falls on the physician's own pay. | CMS final 2026 physician fee schedule, Addendum E

Note: The administrative figures are national surveys by the AMA and MGMA, which represent physicians and practice managers. None is a Hawaiʻi measurement. Payment figures are public Medicare numbers only. No private payer rate appears in this document. Insurer shares are from the AMA's 2026 competition study and are shown without naming any insurer.

YearHawaiʻiUnited States
20145232.1
201551.533.9
201651.634.9
201751.736.7
201852.338.6
201953.140.6
202054.543.5
202156.747
20225950
202360.952.9
202461.854.8

Source: CMS Medicare Geographic Variation.

Section 5. What patients lose: The statewide average hides the island gap

National scorecards rank Hawaiʻi near the top. Those are statewide averages. Broken out by county, public records show fewer visits and shorter lives where doctors are fewest. Every link here between access and an outcome is an association. None proves cause.

MeasureOffice visits
United States15590
Honolulu County13281
Hawaiʻi statewide12206
Maui County11827
Kauaʻi County10201
Hawaiʻi County9820

A Medicare patient in Hawaiʻi County had 9,820 visits per 1,000, against 13,281 in Honolulu and 15,590 nationally.

Source: CMS Medicare Geographic Variation. At Honolulu's visit rate, neighbor-island traditional Medicare patients would have had about 154,000 more office visits in 2024. This is Task Force arithmetic, not a count of visits refused. It leaves out the six in ten Hawaiʻi Medicare patients in Medicare Advantage.

Lung cancer, found late and screened least (Hawaiʻi vs United States):

- 21.9% vs 29.3%: lung cancers caught at an early stage. Hawaiʻi is last of 47 states with data.

- 15.7% vs 24.4%: high-risk residents screened. Hawaiʻi ranks 49th of 50.

- 28.4% vs 31.0%: five-year survival.

Source: American Lung Association, State of Lung Cancer 2026.

Physician shortage (%), 2025; 15; 41; 28; 43

Primary care physician shortage (%), 2025; 13; 35; 8; 14

Residents per primary care physician, 2022; 1,060; 1,230; 1,290; 1,260

Medicare office visits per 1,000, 2024; 13,281; 11,827; 10,201; 9,820

Medicare emergency visits per 1,000, 2024; 501; 486; 555; 518

Life expectancy in years, 2025; 81.7; 81.7; 82.4; 79.5

Premature death per 100,000, 2022; 5,700; 5,800; 6,000; 7,000

Note: Darker cells are further from the best county on that row. Sources: University of Hawaiʻi Physician Workforce Assessment (shortage rows), CMS Medicare Geographic Variation (Medicare rows), County Health Rankings as summarized by the Hawaiʻi Health Data Warehouse (other rows). Hawaiʻi County has the deepest overall physician shortage, but its primary care shortage is close to Honolulu's. Maui County's primary care shortage is the deepest.

CancerLate-stage difference
Lung8.6
Kidney5.6
Esophagus5.5
Prostate5.4
Pancreas4.7
Brain3.8
Thyroid2.1
Uterus1.5
Cervix0.3
Bladder0
Non-Hodgkin lymphoma0
Stomach0
Mouth and throat-1.1
Breast-2.1
Liver-2.2
Colon and rectum-3.3
Melanoma-3.9
Ovary-4.1

Source: National Cancer Institute, State Cancer Profiles. Late stage means regional and distant. Three sites show identical Hawaiʻi and national values on the source page.

What held up:

- Breast and colorectal cancers are found earlier in Hawaiʻi than nationally.

- Only 3.5% of residents were uninsured in 2024, the second-lowest rate of any state (Census Bureau). The access gap is not a coverage gap.

- Emergency visits and preventable admissions among Medicare patients remain below national rates.

Section 6. The money: Hawaiʻi measures primary care spending for Medicaid plans only

Primary care handles about 35% of visits on about 5% of spending (National Academies, 2021). Nationally it received 4.5% of health spending in 2023 counting physicians only, and 12% on a broader definition (Milbank Memorial Fund, 2026 Scorecard).

Hawaiʻi has no law that sets a standard and no report on the commercial or all-payer share. Med-QUEST reviews its own plans against a 10% benchmark, and in 2023 they ranged from 3.7% to 9.4%. HB1965 in 2026 would have set targets of 6, 9 and 12% of total medical spending. It did not pass.

Delaware; Binding floor; 11.5% from 2025 (made permanent in 2026); Fully insured commercial plans; 8.6% in 2024 against a 10% requirement

Oregon; Binding; 12%; Medicaid, public employee and commercial plans; Not reported

Rhode Island; Binding regulation; 10% by the end of 2028; Fully insured commercial plans; 4.7% in 2024

Oklahoma; Binding contract rule; 11% by the fourth contract year; Medicaid managed care; Not reported

Colorado; Binding; Required increases in 2022 and 2023; Commercial plans; Not reported

California; Benchmark; 15% statewide by 2034; Four market segments; Not reported

Connecticut; Target; 10% each year from 2026 to 2030; Statewide reporting; 4.5% in 2023 against a 6.9% target

Hawaiʻi; Did not pass (HB1965 in 2026); 6%, then 9%, then 12% as introduced; Medicaid plans only, against a 10% benchmark; 3.7% to 9.4% across five Medicaid plans in 2023

Note: Each state defines primary care its own way, so the percentages cannot be compared with each other or with the national figures. Measured results are from each state's own report.

Section 7. The asks: What the Task Force asks the state to do

The Task Force asks for no funding in connection with this document.

1. Count independent practices every year. Add ownership questions to the relicensure survey and publish the answers by county. Hawaiʻi's one transaction law (HRS 323D-72) covers hospital acquisitions only. SB3175 in 2026 would have required notice of other health care transactions, including those involving physician organizations. It did not pass.

2. Keep closures, sales and employment changes separate. A practice that is sold and stays open is a different event from one that closes.

3. Publish the employed share every year. It was printed for 2016, 2018, 2020, 2024 and 2025 only.

4. Give independent practices a way into the room that does not cost a clinic day. Take written and after-hours input and report how many took part.

5. Measure what all payers spend on primary care, and report access by island. Med-QUEST already reviews its own plans. Publish the commercial and all-payer share, and show Molokaʻi and Lānaʻi separately.

Section 8. What is missing: What we already know we do not have

Why small-practice physicians left, and who owned what; The count cannot tell retirement from relocation, or an owner from an employee.; The state, through the relicensure survey

Locum tenens and other short-term physicians; The files do not mark locum tenens physicians, so short-term listings can raise the large-group counts.; Task Force check under way: large-group physicians who appear in one snapshot only Added 21 Nov 2026

What CMS changed in its physician listing between 2016 and 2017, and in 2026; Would settle whether the 2016 file can be compared with later years, and whether the 2026 jump is real.; CMS, on request

Paperwork hours and staffing in Hawaiʻi practices; Payers report prior authorization data to the state, but no one has measured the time practices spend.; Task Force members, by survey

Where Hawaiʻi-trained physicians practice after residency; Would show whether new physicians ever enter small practice here.; University of Hawaiʻi

What the 2026 tax exemption is worth to a typical small practice; The Department of Taxation's statewide estimate exists. The effect on one practice is unmeasured.; Department of Taxation

Commercial and all-payer primary care share of Hawaiʻi health spending; Shows whether primary care is funded in line with the care it delivers.; The state, from all-payer claims data

Access below the county line: Molokaʻi, Lānaʻi, Hāna, Kaʻū; County averages hide the places with the least care.; Department of Health

Patients displaced by each closure; Measures the loss in the unit the public feels.; The state, with practices and health plans

The case for employment; Stable pay and no billing office are real benefits. The document does not yet state the other side.; Task Force

Dental, nursing, therapy and behavioral health practices; Independent practice is not only physicians.; Licensing boards

Section 9. Confidence: How sure is each number

Count limited to physicians with a Hawaiʻi practice address; Read with care; Thirteen CMS files. The 2016 file is not used as a starting point. The fall in number is best stated as 6 to 10%, because the CMS list widened nationally in early 2026.

Locum tenens physicians in the large-group count; Read with care; The CMS files carry no flag for locum tenens. A locum who enrolls in Medicare and bills through a hospital group is counted in that group at every snapshot where they are listed, the same as a permanent physician, so short-term physicians can raise the large-group counts. Two parts of the method narrow this without removing it: the main series counts only physicians listed with a Hawaiʻi practice address (3,925 in September 2026, against 5,838 in the full billing file), which takes out most physicians who serve Hawaiʻi from elsewhere; and each figure is a point-in-time count, so a physician who rotates through is counted once per snapshot, not once per assignment. A check of how many large-group physicians appear in a single snapshot only is under way; it gives an upper bound on short-term listings and will be added here. This point was raised by a physician who reviewed the advance copy. Added 21 Nov 2026

Ten-year count by billing group; Confirmed; Same method at every date. The 2026 results reproduce independently computed figures. Leaving the file is not a closure. Billing group is not ownership.

Small-practice physicians by county; Read with care; More than eight in ten could be placed in a county. Neighbor-island counts are small.

Hawaiʻi employed share; Confirmed; Printed in University reports. 2024 and 2025 values are identical, so 2025 may not be a fresh measurement.

U.S. rural independent physicians; Confirmed; PAI advocates for physician practices. Its analysis is not peer-reviewed.

AMA survey shares; Confirmed; Read from the AMA report.

Medicare office visits; Confirmed; CMS file read 17 November 2026. Traditional Medicare only. Not adjusted for health status.

Office visits at Honolulu's rate; Illustration; Task Force arithmetic. Not a count of visits refused.

Cancers found at a late stage; Confirmed; Read again from the National Cancer Institute page on 17 November 2026.

Lung cancer screening and early-diagnosis ranks; Confirmed; American Lung Association, State of Lung Cancer 2026, Hawaiʻi page. Ranks are among states with data for each measure.

County life expectancy, premature death, residents per physician; Confirmed; County Health Rankings as summarized by the Hawaiʻi Health Data Warehouse. The rows come from different editions.

Payment against practice costs; Confirmed; AMA analysis of public Medicare figures. The AMA advocates for physicians.

Prior authorization, regulatory load, claims outage; Read with care; National surveys by advocacy organizations. The outage survey was informal.

What final-year residents want; Read with care; Recruiting firm survey, 241 responses, 2% response rate.

Hawaiʻi prices, tax, departures, physician age, Medicare indexes, wages, uninsured rate; Confirmed; Each opened at its public source: Bureau of Economic Analysis, Act 47 of 2024, University of Hawaiʻi, CMS, Bureau of Labor Statistics and the Census Bureau.

Primary care spending and state targets; Confirmed; Checked against state regulations and reports on 17 November 2026. Several states have bills pending, so check again before relying on it later.

Sources

CMS, Doctors and Clinicians archived data · openICPSR project 149961, CMS Doctors and Clinicians Data, 2014 to 2021 · CMS, Medicare Fee-For-Service Public Provider Enrollment · NBER archive of CMS provider enrollment files · University of Hawaiʻi Physician Workforce Assessment, report to the 2026 Legislature · PAI-Avalere, Rural Physician Employment and Acquisition Trends, 2019 to 2024 · AMA, Physician Practice Characteristics in 2024 · CMS, Medicare Geographic Variation by National, State and County · National Cancer Institute, State Cancer Profiles: Hawaiʻi · Hawaiʻi Health Data Warehouse, County Health Rankings summaries · AMA, Medicare updates compared to inflation, 2001 to 2026 · AMA, 2025 prior authorization physician survey · MGMA, 2026 Regulatory Burden Report · AMA, Change Healthcare survey results · AMN Healthcare, 2023 Survey of Final-Year Medical Residents · Bureau of Economic Analysis, regional price parities · Act 47, Session Laws of Hawaiʻi 2024 · Hawaiʻi Revised Statutes section 323D-72, acquisition of hospital · SB3175 (2026), relating to health care market oversight · Delaware regulation 1322, primary care spending requirements · KFF, Medicare site-neutral payment reforms · MedPAC, June 2026 Report to the Congress · Milbank Memorial Fund 2026 Scorecard, National Academies 2021 report, American Lung Association State of Lung Cancer 2026 and the Census Bureau are cited by name.

Credit and citation

Credit: Analysis by David Isei, MPH, MAOL, PMP, Executive Director, Hawaiʻi Healthcare Task Force.

Original work: The count of physicians by billing-group size, built from thirteen CMS Doctors and Clinicians files and seven CMS enrollment files from 2016 to 2026; the tracking of the same physicians across those files; the county assignment; and the office-visit arithmetic. The underlying files are public. The method, the compiled results and their presentation are the Task Force's.

How to cite: Isei D. Hawaiʻi's Physician Growth Is Bypassing Independent Practice: The Evidence. Hawaiʻi Healthcare Task Force; 2026.

© 2026 Hawaiʻi Healthcare Task Force. Figures may be quoted with the citation above. The compiled datasets, charts and text may not be republished or presented as another organization's analysis without written permission. Truth in the data. Care in the community.

Updates

21 November 2026: published on the Task Force website. Added a confidence note and a "what is missing" row on locum tenens physicians after review by a physician who read the advance copy.

Last checked 21 November 2026